top of page
  • Writer's pictureRebecca Negron

Sharing is Caring? I Don't Think So... Why Children Shouldn't Be Forced To Share.


At Reap & Sow Children’s Center, we work hard to help unlock the potential of every child. Our philosophy, deeply rooted in the importance of free play and co-regulation, emphasizes the importance of children developing at their own pace and in their own unique ways. One aspect of this philosophy that often surprises parents is our stance on sharing: we believe children should not be forced to share their toys. Here’s why:


The Misconception of Forced Sharing


Many of us grew up hearing the mantra, "Sharing is caring," and while the sentiment is lovely, the act of forcing children to share can have unintended consequences. When a child is compelled to give up a toy before they are ready, it can lead to feelings of resentment, confusion, and insecurity. This approach can undermine a child's sense of autonomy and ownership, both of which are crucial for healthy emotional development.


The Power of Ownership


Ownership and the ability to make decisions about one's possessions are essential components of developing a healthy sense of self. When children are allowed to decide when they are ready to share, they learn to recognize and respect their own needs and boundaries. This, in turn, helps them understand and respect the boundaries of others.


The Problem with People Pleasing


Teaching children to share out of obligation can inadvertently teach them to people please – prioritizing others’ feelings over their own needs. This habit, formed early in life, can lead to difficulties in asserting themselves, making independent decisions, and forming authentic relationships in the future. By allowing children to decide when they are ready to share, we encourage them to listen to their own feelings and foster genuine interactions.


Language to Empower Children


Empowering children with the right language can help them express their needs assertively and respectfully. Here are some phrases that parents can teach their children to use when they are not ready to be done with a toy:


- "I'm not done with this toy yet, but you can have it when I'm finished."


- "I’m playing with this right now. How about we play together?"


- "I want to keep using this. Can I give it to you when I’m done?"


- "I’m still using this. Can I help find something else for you?"


Teaching Empathy and Patience


It’s important to balance a child’s right to ownership with the development of empathy and patience. This is why we also encourage children to think about how others feel while also respecting their own feelings. This might look like acknowledging another child’s desire for the toy and suggesting an alternative or setting a timer for turns once the child is ready to share.


Long-Term Benefits


By allowing children to make decisions about sharing, we help them develop crucial life skills:


- Self-Regulation: Understanding and managing their own emotions and behaviors.


- Empathy: Recognizing and respecting the feelings and needs of others.


- Conflict Resolution: Navigating disagreements and finding mutually satisfying solutions.


Creating Healthy Connections


Healthy relationships are built on mutual respect, understanding, and clear boundaries. By not forcing children to share, we help them develop the ability to form connections that are authentic and respectful. They learn that their feelings and needs matter, and that they can honor these while also considering others.


Conclusion


At Reap & Sow Children’s Center, our goal is to nurture well-rounded, emotionally intelligent children. By reframing our approach to sharing, we create an environment where children feel secure, respected, and empowered. This, in turn, lays the foundation for lifelong learning, healthy relationships, and a genuine connection to themselves and others.


Let’s sow the seeds of autonomy and empathy in our children today, and watch them reap the rewards for a lifetime.


If you have any questions or would like to discuss this topic further, feel free to reach out to us at Reap & Sow Children’s Center. We’re here to support you and your child on this incredible journey of growth and discovery.

22 views

Comments


bottom of page